GORUCK Mackall Rucking Shoes (Original)
Last tested:

On this page: Verdict · Our Verified Review · The Good · The Not Good · Product Description · What others think · FAQ
The verdict Not Good: The shape and arch are unnatural, and the arch caused cramping almost immediately.
Our Verified Review
Owned and tested by our reviewer, Will
Will had the original GORUCK Mackall in grey/gum, size 11, and bought them for rucking. For his rucking pants, see his GORUCK Challenge Pants review. For another GORUCK item he tested, see his GORUCK Men’s Performance Tee (ToughMesh) review. For the GORUCK ruck he rates Good, see his GORUCK Rucker 4.0 20L review.
In his words, the shape and arch are unnatural. They ran narrow through the midfoot, putting pressure on the sides of his feet, and the arch was way too aggressive. The arch caused cramping when walking and rucking almost immediately. He gave them a few tries, but this never improved. The fit was not good overall, with a little heel slip and a poor shape.
They are a heavy and rugged shoe. He bought them for rucking, and they would not be a good option for training or running; they are just too heavy and bulky. He had to stop using them before he could form an opinion on longevity. In his words, not a good pair of shoes. His verdict: Not Good.
For a rucking shoe Will did rate Good, see his INOV8 Mens Roclite™ GTX® review.
For a rucking boot Will did rate Good, see his Garmont Nemesis 4 G-Dry Tactical Boots review.
The Good ✅
- Rugged: A heavy and rugged shoe, built for rucking.
The Not Good ❌
The deal-breaker is tagged.
- Deal-breaker Unnatural Shape and Arch: The arch was way too aggressive and caused cramping when walking and rucking almost immediately, and it never improved.
- Narrow Midfoot: Ran narrow through the midfoot, putting pressure on the sides of his feet.
- Heel Slip: A little heel slip.
- Too Heavy for Training or Running: Too heavy and bulky for training or running.
Product Description
Specs and maker’s details
The GORUCK Mackall is a low-top rucking and trail shoe named for Camp Mackall, the home of Special Forces training. GORUCK lists an aggressive triple compound outsole, an EVA midsole that wraps the upper for stability, a polyester knit upper with TPU reinforcement, a dual-layered toe cap, a 13mm heel-to-toe drop, a wide toe box and a dual density insert, at 13.5 ounces in size 9. GORUCK now also sells the Mackall 45 alongside the original (Mackall collection).
Will’s were the original Mackall in grey/gum, size 11.
Spec check: GORUCK lists the Mackall with a 13mm heel-to-toe drop and 13.5 ounces per shoe in size 9, a much higher drop than the INOV8 Mens Roclite™ GTX® (18mm heel / 12mm forefoot midsole stack, 365g) and the zero-drop Altra Lone Peak 9 GTX (12.15 oz), and lighter than the Garmont Nemesis 4 G-Dry Tactical Boots (490g, size 9).
What others think
How our verdict compares with other reviews
Overall reception: Positive overall. GORUCK’s current Mackall page shows 4.6 out of 5 from 1,219 reviews. That page sells the current version, so the figure may not reflect the original Will wore.
Where owners agree: Owners like the supportive, grippy sole for rucking under weight and how durable the shoe feels.
Where owners disagree: Fit. Some report heel slip, early rubbing and blisters, a toe box that’s narrow for wide feet, and an arch that some flat-footed owners find too aggressive, while many say it fits well.
Our take: Will is on the fit side of the split. His deal-breaker is the unnatural shape and arch: it cramped his feet almost immediately and never improved, so he stopped wearing them.
Sources (checked Oct 18, 2026): GORUCK Mackall product page
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to common questions
Is the GORUCK Mackall good?
Will says Not Good. The shape and arch felt unnatural to him, and the arch caused cramping when walking and rucking almost immediately.
How does the Mackall fit?
For Will, it ran narrow through the midfoot, putting pressure on the sides of his feet. He also had a little heel slip.
Did the arch get better with time?
No. Will gave them a few tries, but the cramping never improved.
Can you use the Mackall for training or running?
Will says they would not be a good option for training or running. They are just too heavy and bulky.
How durable is the GORUCK Mackall?
Will had to stop using them before he could form an opinion on longevity.
This review comes from Will, the founder of GoodNotGood. A big thank-you to everyone who visits. GoodNotGood was built on one idea: authentic opinions from people who actually use the products they review. If you have thoughts on this review, the site, or something you’d like to see reviewed, leave a comment below. We read every one.
Welcome to GoodNotGood.
Every review on this site comes from an actual person who has owned, used, and lived with the product. No spec sheets. No press kits. No ghostwritten fluff.
We don’t pretend to be perfectly objective or subject matter experts. We don’t chase stars or clicks. We just tell you honestly what we thought — the good, the not good, and everything in between.
In the age of synthetic content, the most valuable thing we can offer is simple authenticity.
One real person. One real experience. Take it or leave it.
More information on our reviews and our review philosophy
Was this review helpful?
Thanks for the feedback!





Own this? Tell us if it's Good or Not Good for you
Tick “I own it” to vote. One vote per review, no sign-in, no personal data stored.
Votes come from readers who say they own it. They aren't verified and don't change our verdict.