New to GoodNotGood? Every review here comes from someone who actually used the gear, and each one ends with a plain verdict: Good or Not Good. Here are the standouts in each category. (More about who we are.)
Curious how a review gets made? Here’s how we review.
Tactical Fitness
Gear for tactical fitness training and competitions, in six groups:
Belts & Holsters
Battle belts and holsters, including the ones that didn’t make the cut.
- Warriorland Kydex AIWB Holster: Good. Cheap slip holsters that protect the trigger and keep the gun put.
- Black Scorpion Gear Level II Duty Drop & Offset Holster: Good. Great retention and a smooth draw after about two years of tactical fitness events.
- AR500 Armor AR Battle Belt: Not Good. Limited holster compatibility and poor all-day comfort led Will to retire it quickly.
Mag & Med Pouches
Pistol and rifle mag pouches, IFAK pouches and a tourniquet.
- North American Rescue C-A-T Tourniquet (Gen 7): Good. Carried on the outside of Will’s IFAK, and he has practiced it on himself.
- 5.11 Tactical UCR IFAK Pouch: Not Good. Pulls open easily, but it’s bulky, bounces around and costs too much for a simple pouch.
- Black Scorpion Gear AR-15 Mag Pouch: Not Good. Retention screws that would not get tight enough left mags insecure.
Plate Carriers & Rucking
Plate carriers and steel weight plates for weighted training.
- Ferro Concepts Slickster Plate Carrier: Good. Sleek, secure and bounce-free; a plate carrier that actually fits a 5’1″ frame.
- 5.11 Tactical TacTec Plate Carrier: Good. An excellent hybrid plate carrier that blends tactical functionality with the comfort needed for fitness and tactical competitions.
- 5.11 Tactical PT-R 8.75 lb Steel Weight Plates: Good. Tough, rust-free plates that ride snug in the TacTec through years of training.
Tactical Boots & Clothing
Tactical boots and tactical clothing for rucking and range days.
- Garmont Nemesis 4 G-Dry Tactical Boots: Good. A snug, rugged hybrid boot with zero break-in. Pick it for function, not style.
- Howitzer Viscusi Women’s Tactical Leggings: Good. A Medium that fits well at 5’1″, with belt loops that make sense at a tactical fitness event.
Range Gear & Storage
A range bag plus rifle and handgun cases for range days.
- Evolution Outdoor Range Bag: Good. About five years of use so far. Right size for a quick range trip, too small as a competition bag.
- Savior American Classic 42″ Double Rifle Case: Good. It has survived rain, mud and five tactical fitness competitions. Weight is the biggest downside.
- Allen 11-Inch Cloth Handgun Case: Good. Simple, cheap and light, and they keep guns protected from scratches in the safe and range bag.
Women’s Gear
Finding tactical fitness and range gear that actually works for women is harder than it should be. So much of it is built for bigger frames, or is just a smaller or recolored version of the men’s gear, and plate carriers, belts and ear muffs often don’t fit. That leaves a lot of women buying, returning, or living with gear that never quite works. Every review here comes from Andrea, who is 5’1″ and has trained and competed in this gear, so you’ll know what fit her smaller frame, like the Grey Ghost UGF belt, and what didn’t, like the 5.11 TacTec plate carrier and the Walker’s Razor muffs.
- Ferro Concepts Kangaroo Front Flap Magazine Carrier: Good. At 5’1″, Andrea says it sits perfectly, keeps the vest slick and makes grabbing a mag very easy.
- SIG Sauer P365-AXG Legion: Good. It fits Andrea’s hand, is easy to conceal and is highly reliable after over a year of range time and daily carry.
- Walker’s Razor Electronic Muffs: Not Good. The sound works well, but they don’t fit Andrea’s smaller frame.
See all Tactical Fitness reviews →
Firearms
Pistols, rifles, optics and gun accessories we’ve actually shot.
Guns
Carry pistols and full-size pistols.
- Glock 19X: Good. No break-in needed, runs any ammo Will has tried and has a better trigger than a standard 19 or 17. A little too large to carry, but a great go-bag gun.
- SIG Sauer P320 X5 Legion: Good. Very accurate, soft-shooting and reliable through thousands of rounds. The trigger is the weakest link.
- Glock 43: Not Good. Good for smaller hands, but Andrea didn’t like the grip, and it had malfunctions and was not reliable.
Optics & Sights
Red dots, enclosed sights and holographic sights.
- Holosun EPS Enclosed Pistol Sight: Good. Rugged, easy on batteries and great in wet, dirty conditions. Just upgrade the plate.
- Holosun EPS Carry (Red MRS, Solar): Good. No zero issues and a reliable shake awake over three years of carry, but the screws needed modifying.
- EOTech EXPS3-0 Holographic Sight (Black, Red): Good. Clear, rugged, very bright, and it always holds zero.
Firearm Accessories
Magazines, optic plates and slings.
- Magpul PMAG 15 GL9 Glock 19 Magazine: Good. They function just like the factory version and have been 100% reliable so far. Fine for carry in a pinch.
- C&H Precision V4 Plate for SIG P320 X5 / Holosun EPS: Good. Mounts a Holosun EPS on Will’s SIG P320 X5 Legion flush and tight after the Holosun-supplied plate failed him.
- Blue Force Gear Vickers Combat Applications Sling: Good. Solid, stays put and no slip on Will’s BCM RECCE-16.
Fitness & Training
Lifting, gym, running and nutrition gear.
Gym Equipment
Lifting straps, wrist wraps and sweatbands.
- Rogue Ohio Lifting Straps: Good. Easy to set up, very secure and no fraying after over two years of Olympic lifting.
- Rogue Wrist Wraps (12-inch): Good. Worn forever for overhead lifts and CrossFit workouts, and they never really wear out.
- Rogue Wrist Bands (Sweatbands): Good. Their length keeps Will’s hands dry in long, sweaty outdoor South Florida workouts, even after hundreds of washes.
Shoes
Gym, running and trail shoes.
- Reebok CrossFit Nano X5: Good. A solid all-around indoor gym shoe with good stability for lifting, versatile enough for rope climbs, carries, drags and short runs.
- Brooks Ghost Running Shoes: Good. A great medium-cushioned road running shoe and an excellent entry point for new runners.
- Brooks Cascadia 19 GTX: Not Good. It ran narrow and caused foot cramping, and the mushy midsole felt unstable under load.
Apparel
Training tees and pants.
- NOBULL Men’s Tee: Good. Very light, non-restrictive and breathable even when soaked through a humid South Florida summer.
- Gymreapers Basic Tee: Not Good. An excellent fit, sabotaged by a fabric that can’t handle real sweat.
- REI Co-op Trailmade Pants (Men’s): Good. Inexpensive, lightweight and unrestricted for range and training, though they stretch out over a hard day.
Nutrition
Protein, pre-workout and a daily multivitamin.
- MusclePharm Pro Series Clear-ISO: Good. Light, refreshing and easy on an empty stomach.
- Naked Energy Pre-Workout: Good. Sustained energy and digestive comfort from a clean-label pre-workout.
- Ancient Nutrition Multivitamin for Men: Good. A multi that replaces a whole shelf of supplements; smells like ramen, works like a pro.
See all Fitness & Training reviews → (Tactical Fitness gear has its own section above.)
Outdoor & Sports
Packs, bags and sports gear for travel, trails and everyday days out.
Packs & Bags
Everyday, travel and day packs and bags.
- The North Face Surge Backpack: Good. Well built, with years of commuting and travel that do not show at all, and above-average comfort.
- YETI Crossroads 60L Duffel: Good. Will’s range bag: tough zippers, plenty of handles and a look that doesn’t stand out.
See all Outdoor & Sports reviews →
Electronics
Everyday tech: smartwatches, fitness trackers, a photo frame and more.
- Fitbit Inspire 3: Good. Easy to charge, a little over a week per charge, info at a glance and helpful reminders to move.
- Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra2: Good. Long battery life and very accurate GPS, but it is a big watch.
- Skylight Frame 10″ Digital Picture Frame: Good. Bright screen and easy sharing, with no Plus subscription needed for Andrea.
New to some of the gear terms? Our Gear Glossary explains words like KeyMod, QD, MOLLE and rucking in plain English.
Want everything in one place? Browse all reviews →