SIG Sauer P320 21-Round 9mm Magazine (Coyote)
Last tested:

On this page: Verdict · Our Verified Review · The Good · The Not Good · Product Description · What others think · FAQ
The verdict Good: No malfunctions, and no issues over literally thousands of rounds.
Our Verified Review
Owned and tested by our reviewer, Will
Will has five of the SIG P320 21-round magazines with the FDE base pad: four of the new ones and one of the old ones with the black follower and limited witness holes. All of them, new and old, have a little witness hole by the base pad that lets you know they’re fully loaded, a feature he really likes.
He has had no malfunctions. They seat really well in his P320 X5 Legion with an audible, tactile click. They fit fairly loose, which also lets them eject quickly and reliably without any shaking or tugging. He likes that they hang out of the bottom just a bit, so if one ever hangs up, or you want to check it’s seated, you have a good amount of magazine to grab and tug. The 17-round mags that came with the gun sit flush with the magwell and don’t allow this.
They easily take the full 21 rounds with only a minor break-in period, and they’re easy to seat when totally full with a closed slide, which is not the case in many other pistols. The one thing to be aware of: on sandy enough days, they get dirty enough that the follower hangs up and they turn into Pez dispensers. It’s an easy fix to pop the base pad off and run a rag or brush through them, but something to know if you drop them on the ground during a competition. The finish and base plate have had no issues over literally thousands of rounds, reloads, cleanings and competitions. His verdict: Good.
The Good ✅
- No Malfunctions: No malfunctions over thousands of rounds.
- Full-Load Witness Hole: A witness hole by the base pad shows when they’re fully loaded.
- Seats and Drops Free: Seats with an audible, tactile click and ejects without shaking or tugging.
- Takes All 21: Takes the full 21 after a minor break-in, and seats full with a closed slide.
- Durable Finish: No issues with the finish or base plate.
The Not Good ❌
Flaws, but not deal-breakers.
- Sand Can Hang the Follower: On sandy days the follower can hang up; pop the base pad and clean them.
Product Description
Specs and maker’s details
The SIG Sauer 21-round 9mm P320 magazine is SIG’s factory extended magazine for the P320 family, with a coyote base plate. The newer versions have an orange follower and round-count witness holes on the back.
Will runs his in a P320 X5 Legion. He has carried them in the Black Scorpion Gear double stack mag pouches, the Blue Force Gear Mag NOW! Double Pistol Pouch and the 5.11 Flex Double Pistol Mag Pouch 2.0.
What others think
How our verdict compares with other reviews
Overall reception: Very positive. SIG’s product page for the coyote-base magazine shows 4.9 out of 5 from 758 reviews.
Where owners agree: Owners say SIG’s factory 21-rounders run reliably and fit the P320 family, including models with a magwell, and some prefer them to the shorter mags.
Where owners disagree: Feeding and bulk. Some report occasional failures to feed, though many trace them to something other than the mag, and some find the extra length and weight a drawback when carried. Cheaper aftermarket versions get much worse reviews.
Our take: Will agrees with the praise. He has had no malfunctions over thousands of rounds, and his only tip is to clean them after sandy days when the follower can hang up.
Sources (checked Oct 18, 2026): SIG Sauer product page and reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to common questions
Is the SIG P320 21-round magazine good?
Will says Good. He has had no malfunctions, and the finish and baseplate have had no issues over thousands of rounds.
Do the SIG 21-round mags hold a full 21?
Yes. Will says they easily take the full 21 rounds with only a minor break-in period, and they’re easy to seat totally full with a closed slide.
Do they drop free?
Yes. They fit fairly loose in his P320 X5 Legion, which lets them eject quickly and reliably without any shaking or tugging.
Do the 21-rounders get dirty?
On sandy enough days, Will says the follower can hang up. It’s an easy fix: pop the base pad off and run a rag or brush through them.
How do they compare with the 17-round mags?
The 21-rounders hang out of the bottom a bit, so you have magazine to grab and tug. The 17-round mags that came with his gun sit flush with the magwell.
This review comes from Will, the founder of GoodNotGood. A big thank-you to everyone who visits. GoodNotGood was built on one idea: authentic opinions from people who actually use the products they review. If you have thoughts on this review, the site, or something you’d like to see reviewed, leave a comment below. We read every one.
Welcome to GoodNotGood.
Every review on this site comes from an actual person who has owned, used, and lived with the product. No spec sheets. No press kits. No ghostwritten fluff.
We don’t pretend to be perfectly objective or subject matter experts. We don’t chase stars or clicks. We just tell you honestly what we thought — the good, the not good, and everything in between.
In the age of synthetic content, the most valuable thing we can offer is simple authenticity.
One real person. One real experience. Take it or leave it.
More information on our reviews and our review philosophy
Was this review helpful?
Thanks for the feedback!





Own this? Tell us if it's Good or Not Good for you
Tick “I own it” to vote. One vote per review, no sign-in, no personal data stored.
Votes come from readers who say they own it. They aren't verified and don't change our verdict.