Firearm Reviews: Good

Pistols and rifles we’ve actually shot in training, at the range and in matches. Notes on reliability, recoil, triggers and setup, with optics and gun accessories in their own sections. Each gets a plain verdict: Good or Not Good.

12 reviews10 Good2 Not Good

SIG Sauer P938 Legion

Andrea has had her SIG Sauer P938 Legion for a few years and carries it in her purse. It's simple, perfect for smaller hands, easy to rack, and worth the price. Verdict: Good.

SIG Sauer M400 TREAD

Elmir has run his SIG Sauer M400 TREAD with a 16-inch barrel and SIG 1x6 optic for six years in tactical fitness competitions. Super reliable, no functional issues, a great entry rifle. Verdict: Good.

BCM RECCE-16 KMR-A

Will has put roughly 2,500 to 3,000 rounds through his black BCM RECCE-16 KMR-A in training and competing. 100% reliable with above-average accuracy, but a heavy trigger and gassy recoil. Verdict: Good.

Sprinco Blue enhanced power AR-15 carbine buffer spring with blue color-coded end

Sprinco Blue Enhanced Power AR-15 Buffer Spring

Will has run a Sprinco Blue buffer spring with a BCM H2 buffer in his BCM RECCE-16 for a year. Much softer shooting, easier follow-up shots, no malfunctions and an easy drop-in install. Verdict: Good.

Blue Force Gear Vickers Combat Applications Sling

Will runs a standard (unpadded) Blue Force Gear Vickers sling in FDE with QD swivels and the plastic-ball adjuster on his BCM RECCE-16. Solid, stays put, no slip. Verdict: Good.

BCM KeyMod QD Sling Mount

Will runs two BCM KeyMod QD sling mounts on his rifle for range and competition use. Low-profile, stays tight, and the QD swivel locks without unexpected releases. Verdict: Good.

BCM H2 Carbine Buffer

Will runs a BCM H2 carbine buffer with a Sprinco Blue spring in his BCM RECCE-16. Simple toolless install that cleaned up ejection and softened recoil over about 2,000 rounds. Verdict: Good.

SIG Sauer P320 X5 Legion

Will runs his SIG Sauer P320 X5 Legion for matches, range and home. Very accurate, soft-shooting and reliable through thousands of rounds. The trigger is the weakest link. Verdict: Good.

Holosun EPS full-size enclosed red dot pistol sight product photo

Holosun EPS Enclosed Pistol Sight

Will runs the full-size Holosun EPS (red 2 MOA dot) on his SIG P320 X5 Legion. Rugged, easy on batteries and great in wet, dirty competitions. Just upgrade the plate. Verdict: Good.

SIG Sauer P365-AXG Legion

Andrea, who is 5'1", has carried her SIG Sauer P365-AXG Legion with an optic for over a year for range time, competition and daily carry. It fits her hand, is easy to conceal and is highly reliable. Verdict: Good.